Non-contact (observation only) elephant sanctuaries
There is an alternative to visitor bathing experiences. Many of the elephant sanctuaries that we would consider truly ethical, such as
Hidden Forest Elephant Reserve in Phuket, are either strictly observation-only, or are moving in that direction. Visitors watch from a distance, perhaps may walk alongside the elephants, but have no direct physical contact with them. Observation-only means no commands, no chains, no control.
At these sanctuaries you might accompany the elephants as they make their way down to the water then watch either from the riverbank or, ideally from a safety perspective, from a specially built platform or walkway. We’d argue that this kind of experience is more satisfying than bathing the elephants yourself, because you can watch them having fun and behaving completely naturally. They can move around freely, and leave the water whenever they want.
Another take on how bathing elephants at sanctuaries can be done in a safe and humane way comes from one of our India holiday partners, who suggests visitors can watch the washing being done by trained caretakers, with the animals given treats or special attention as a reward for their cooperation. “We should let visitors watch the normal bathing routine but it should not be a special tourist show.”